Economist and author Christopher Whalen joined Chicago’s Morning Answer with Dan Proft to discuss the economic and political challenges facing major U.S. cities, using New York as a case study in the intersection of housing policy, inflation, and progressive politics.
Whalen said he agrees with columnist George Will’s belief that occasional “contained experiments” with socialism can demonstrate its failures. But in the case of New York City’s mayoral race, he argued the situation is neither contained nor harmless. He said the leading candidate’s proposals — including a rent freeze and expanded free services — may be popular, but they will not address the city’s core problem: the high cost of living.
According to Whalen, inflation has made New York unaffordable for all but high earners. He pointed to the New York City Housing Authority as an example of unsustainable public spending, noting that the city charges tenants about $1,500 per month for units that cost $5,000 per month to operate, losing thousands of dollars per apartment across half a million units. “That’s a classic Soviet-style enterprise,” he said.
The problem, Whalen argued, is structural. Unionized building staff, rising operating expenses, and rent controls make much of the city’s multifamily housing financially nonviable. He warned that a socialist mayor could further erode property values, potentially causing bank failures. Even if the government sells multifamily assets currently financed by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, Whalen said, buyers may struggle to make the numbers work unless rents can rise in line with costs.
While Proft raised concerns about relocating low-income residents from city centers to surrounding suburbs — a strategy that in Chicago’s past led to community destabilization — Whalen said he supports resettling families into smaller cities and towns along transit corridors, where they can access schools, services, and job opportunities. He cited his own move from Manhattan to Westchester County as an example of how households can dramatically cut expenses and improve quality of life.
Whalen also tied the housing crisis to a broader political trend, warning that persistent inflation without deficit reduction will continue to drive voters toward socialist policies nationwide. He said the economic environment is still strong due to deficit spending and abundant market liquidity, but the long-term pressures of housing affordability remain unresolved.
Looking ahead, Whalen said the answer lies in returning to market-based real estate pricing and targeting subsidies to working families rather than attempting blanket low-income housing mandates through entities like Fannie and Freddie. “Get people into places where they can put down stakes,” he said. “That’s how you start to turn this around.”
Photo by Maria Lin Kim on Unsplash